Ive used both dayco and gates.... dayco is junk, has a plastic idler wheel that looks like its glued together in 2 or 3 different pieces, it is almost square. the gates is heavy duty and has a steel idler wheel that wont wear out, I have seen posts where some trucks do require the tensioner needs to be shimmed.
dayco belt will squeek on shut down, the good year gater back belt will not make any noise.
now that I think about it, I believe the pics below was an OEM and a goodyear tensioner
can you spot the oem ?
here is an idler wheel that saw alot of miles..