You are basically comparing a 34x11.50 tire (285/75-17) to a 34x12.00 tire so their is very little differenc. Both will look great, but the Toyo is a better tire so I'd go with them.
Im tryin to go as big as i can without any lift. I plan on a lift but thats a few years down the road. So 285-295 are gunna do it for me i think. I dont need to kill my turning radius