Your truck weighs more than 800 lbs over a 1500.... think my 1500 was under 6klbs. My 2500 weighs 8500. Massive difference. If that’s what your saying? But even 500lb changes how a tire can act.If they had gotten 52K miles out of them i would buy another set, but they only have 52k kms on them which is piss poor. Add on top of the poor lifespan one of my sledding buddies has them on his half ton and hes always the on getting stuck on trips, so they haven't done anything to impress me.
And for they toyos, My dad has ran them on his past two 1500s and driving them in the winter they did a excellent job, even when towing the sled trailer. I don't see how the extra 800 pounds my truck weights over his would make a major difference in their handling.
Wierd to have issues getting stuck with duratracs. Me and friends who run them have had no traction issues. One would be clay needs wheel speed to help clean.
I was about to go Toyo but talked to a few friends and brother, who had them and hated winter ability. That was my main goal getting a tire, since I don’t plan on taking my heavy truck in the mud.