Dodge Cummins or Ford Powerstroke

[1-TON]

Well I here that ferd is trying to make their own diesel. Has anyone else heard this?

__________________

2005 3500, QUAD-CAB, 6-SPEED, 2WD, 61K MILES, AEM WORK HORSE CAI, MUFFLER IS MIA

[rufushusky]

Originally Posted by 1-TON

Well I here that ferd is trying to make their own diesel. Has anyone else heard this?

Yeah that has been floating around for a while but because of the 6.0 issues it has really gain momentum. I don't see them bouncing out of the contract with international anytime soon...too big of an investment.

__________________
Dennis
04.5 Ram 2500 Reg Cab 4x4 5.9, 48re, AEM, Smarty, Banks High Ram,FASS HPFP, Boost/pyro/trans/FP/RP gauges, 5" Exhaust, Cat 2 micron fuel filter, Amsoil Bypass, Reese Hitch, Single Disc Converter w/ Strictly Diesel VB
1997 Fleetwood Prowler 26.5"
Check out: Rig of the Month!
http://www.cumminsforum.com/forum/rig-month/

[Moparman]

Originally Posted by 02_laramie

The cummins engine is built tougher it uses alot of the technolgy that they use for their big diesels. 1. cummins engines use grid heaters instead of glow plugs and therefore when its 50 degrees outside u dont have to crank on your truck for an hour 2. ease of under the hood access minor stuff on a powerstroke can be a nightmare they do all they can to cram that big pile of crap under the hood and u cant hardly get to anything on a powerstroke, look under the hood of a dodge and it looks like an 81 chevy 350 wide open bay, where as a powerstroke looks like the hood under a mini van u cant have easy access to anything. 3. you can get alot more power out of a cummins peformance wise... and lastly international uses cats cummins and detroits in semi's because well they make junk

All of this plus as said in another post above the Cummins makes its power lower in the rpm band where you need it, and that's the reason the big rig diesels are inline 6s. I would strongly suggest you get the 5.9L cummins as the new 6.7 gets much worse fuel mileage, and the 5.9L has tons of aftermarket mods for it.

I have seen 5.9s with 1000-1200+hp and 2000+ torque and they're still getting 17-20mpg on the highway. 500hp/1000+torque is very doable without breaking your bank account. The Cummins is far more capable of making big hp than the Powerstroke. Twin turbos on the 6.4 Powerjoke and it makes 350hp?? Please.

Yes the 47-48RE dodge trannies are the weak link but there are inexpensive fixes for them, or you could go with the 6speed manual and get really great mileage. Mine gets over 23mpg at 65mph.

Go with the Cummins you'll never look back.

__________________
2006 white quad cab Dodge dually, G56, True Flow XDI air filter system, FilterMag, am/fm/cd/sirius, Fluidampr, LineX bedliner, 3.73, gooseneck hitch, Mag-Hytec rear diff cover, rear bags w/ in-cab controls, P235/80R17 Michelin LTX M&S on stock wheels

[jimmarla]

Any V-8 diesel is a converted gas engine. The Cummins is a TRUE diesel engine,its inline, The CUMMINS IS THE LONGEST LASTING, BEST DIESEL ENGINE MADE that is put in pickup trucks by far!! Its not even close. Like the ole saying goes,"90 percent of FORD trucks are still on the road today, the other 10 percent made it home!!!" Just my .02

[Boosted]

Ok I guess I am the devils advocate here. the cummins motor is fantastic. Great power and pulls like crazy. The dodge truck though is about 5 years behind the time. Wait let me put my fire suite on before all the flaming starts.

The idea truck for me would be the Ford F250 4X4 with the 5.9 cummins and the Allison 1000 out of the Duramax trucks. I have owned 2 of the Duramax's. An lb7 305hp motor and the lbz 365hp motor. Both ran great, both had plenty of power, both cost big $$$. This is why I am in a 99 Cummins.. i still wanted a diesel but did not want to pay $40k for one..


I don't know what chevy forum yo uare on but if you think you might want to consider a duramax I would suggest GM-Diesel.com Information, and discussion, related to General Motors line of diesel engines, including the new Duramax, and other diesels in general. or the sister site to this one duramaxforums.com

Both of these sites have good information and the guys there are willing to help just like the ones here. I personaly would not buy a Ford unless I can get it in my configuration. I would buy another duramax in a heartbeat <----- No pun intended.

__________________

96 Club Cab 2wd 7.3

450RWHP 870TQ

NHDRA #4495

[rufushusky]

Originally Posted by Boosted

Ok I guess I am the devils advocate here. the cummins motor is fantastic. Great power and pulls like crazy. The dodge truck though is about 5 years behind the time. Wait let me put my fire suite on before all the flaming starts.

The idea truck for me would be the Ford F250 4X4 with the 5.9 cummins and the Allison 1000 out of the Duramax trucks. I have owned 2 of the Duramax's. An lb7 305hp motor and the lbz 365hp motor. Both ran great, both had plenty of power, both cost big $$$. This is why I am in a 99 Cummins.. i still wanted a diesel but did not want to pay $40k for one..


I don't know what chevy forum yo uare on but if you think you might want to consider a duramax I would suggest GM-Diesel.com Information, and discussion, related to General Motors line of diesel engines, including the new Duramax, and other diesels in general. or the sister site to this one duramaxforums.com

Both of these sites have good information and the guys there are willing to help just like the ones here. I personaly would not buy a Ford unless I can get it in my configuration. I would buy another duramax in a heartbeat <----- No pun intended.

Man that is the idea truck for a lot of people, myself included:thumbsup

__________________
Dennis
04.5 Ram 2500 Reg Cab 4x4 5.9, 48re, AEM, Smarty, Banks High Ram,FASS HPFP, Boost/pyro/trans/FP/RP gauges, 5" Exhaust, Cat 2 micron fuel filter, Amsoil Bypass, Reese Hitch, Single Disc Converter w/ Strictly Diesel VB
1997 Fleetwood Prowler 26.5"
Check out: Rig of the Month!
http://www.cumminsforum.com/forum/rig-month/

[TXLawDawg]

I actually debated on getting a 07 Powerstroke as a friend of mine has a 06 F250 King Ranch with one and I really liked it when I would drive it. Had lots of power and I loved the interior. However, when I went and test drove the other two, I loved the dodge. Although rated at less hp and tq, there was a notable difference in how the truck had more grunt to it. The duramax would get up and go and was super fast feeling but it didn't have that low end grunt like the cummins. I had never owned a diesel pickup before and as far as brand loyalty would go, I had always had Chevy/GMC trucks. You should have seen the guys face at the dealership (they had all three - ford, dodge, and chevy) when I told him that I liked the dodge better. He said no one had ever driven all three and came back and said they liked the dodge better. The chevy and ford do, without a doubt, have a better interior as the dodge is quite dated. But when it came down to it, the dodge with the cummins (5.9) won hands down so that's what I went with. My friend with the powerstroke absolutely loves the way my truck drives, sounds, and pulls. Now I seriously doubt he'd go out and buy one (he is extremely loyal to Ford) but he gets a kick out of driving mine. Now with all that said...I think you should go with dodge...I've been extremely happy with mine. However, it's up to you and what you think suits your needs best. Go out and drive the ford and the dodge and see what you think you like best. I don't think the powerstroke is a bad engine I just think the cummins is better. Happy hunting

__________________
2007 2500 5.9 4x4 3.73 48RE / 315-70-17 Firestone Destination AT's / 2" Coil Spacers / No cat / Diablo Sport Predator / Quadzilla Commander / Silencer Ring MIA / AEM Brute Force

[cesibley]

Cummins - I6 - 7 Main Bearings for 6 Cylinders
Power Stroke - V8 - 5 Main Bearings for 8 Cylinders

Which engine do you think is more bulletproof?

[DieselFarmin]

My last dodge has 220,000 on the odometer with only a fuel pump replaced. Never a tranny issue, and it did pleny of towing. On the other hand, my friend has a 05 6.0 Powerstroke for three months and half of that has been in the shop. It's had three or four new injectors, two turbos, and a few other smaller odds and ends. Also, at work, we have an 06 6.0, and it is on its third turbo in th first 10,000 miles. The 7.3's were excellent, but the 6.0's have always been terrible. As far as the dodge truck itself, it doesn't have as good of a reputation, but we've farmed with them and always had fewer problems than ford or chevy. Just my 2 cents worth.

__________________
Inferno Red '07 2500 5.9 Quad Cab Big Horn 4X4. 3.73's Line-X X-tra over the rail, Stainless rockers, 285/70R17 BFG TA KO's and B&W gooseneck.
IAFF LOCAL 1897

One thing Ford has that I'm using now is a system called Oasis. Some one on that forum has access to it and with VIN numbers is able to call up any maintenance that has been performed at a Ford dealership. Does anyone know if Dodge has anything like this?

---

Last edited by Ruckuz : 08-21-2007 at 11:58 PM.

[dodge325]

you will want to put bleach in your eyes and pencils in your ears if you buy a ford. doesnt matter which one, they all suck. i honestly dont know how people can drive & work on them. the cummins is the best motor out there, from either working on it, power upgrades, towing. its the best all around motor.

__________________
06 2500 quad cab long bed 4x4 auto ppe recon bully dog gauges MBRP Cool Duals afe stage2
OLD RIG! 2001 2500 quad cab 61psi boost super phat shaft 62 turbo 130 hp injectors hrvp44 suncoast trans autometer gauges afe stage 2 NOS spearco intercooler

[Boosted]

Originally Posted by dodge325

you will want to put bleach in your eyes and pencils in your ears if you buy a ford. doesnt matter which one, they all suck. i honestly dont know how people can drive & work on them. the cummins is the best motor out there, from either working on it, power upgrades, towing. its the best all around motor.

well everyone knows the cummins is top dog in diesels, but there is more to a truck than a motor.. Ride and appearnce are major factors also.

__________________

96 Club Cab 2wd 7.3

450RWHP 870TQ

NHDRA #4495